A number of days in the past, whereas scrolling by the Mercedes-Benz EQS/EQS SUV Fb group, I stumbled upon an intriguing put up from Srikanth Katrue. His put up learn, “Hiya everybody, what has been your upkeep on EQS SUV first few years? My spouse is debating between EQS 580 SUV three-row vs Kia EV9 vs Tesla Mannequin X. Any assistance is appreciated.” His query sparked a energetic debate amongst group members, and the responses offered an insightful perspective on the real-world possession experiences of those three electrical SUVs.
For anybody contemplating a high-end, three-row EV, the alternatives could be dizzying. Srikanth’s dilemma is comprehensible—how do you select between the futuristic luxurious of a Mercedes-Benz EQS 580, the family-friendly practicality of a Kia EV9, and the cutting-edge tech and efficiency of the Tesla Mannequin X? Let’s break it down, beginning with the group’s responses.
Actual-World Recommendation from EQS, Tesla, and Kia House owners
Sam Elenia weighed in with a compelling perspective, saying, “Get a used 3-row 2024 EQS 580 for the worth of Kia and luxurious that is unparalleled to Tesla. Tesla is extra enjoyable to drive although. I went from Mannequin X to Mannequin S and now EQS 580. I additionally advise that you just attempt to lease an EQS and Mannequin X for twenty-four hours. My spouse prefers Tesla for causes that I am unable to comprehend whereas I desire EQS and I dislike Tesla. I might get a 2024 EQS over the 2023 largely due to the brakes glitch and a bit bit extra miles.”
Jo Ki added an emphatic take: “You actually can’t examine the three. Solely a type of is a luxurious automobile. Will depend on what you need, but when it’s luxurious, then it’s Mercedes.”
In the meantime, Christopher Barclay shared a extra nuanced view: “Have her drive the 580, then it will likely be simple as the opposite two are a step down in luxurious and luxury. We simply removed our Teslas and purchased a 2024 EQE SUV and EQS. Couldn’t be happier. After coming from Tesla, I had forgotten what good service was. My Tesla was not a superb expertise.”
Sam Fran chimed in, “Undoubtedly EQS 580. I had a Tesla and switched to EQS 580. It is an incredible automobile. My associate has Kia and the journey just isn’t the identical as EQS. You may’t examine it.”
Curiously, Pakman Pak supplied a balanced viewpoint: “I’ve each the EQS and the Rivian R1S. Each are superior in their very own manner.” And Grayson Ang, a moderator, introduced up an essential consideration for budget-conscious patrons: “EV9 will in all probability be extra dependable and cheaper to restore out of guarantee.”
So, what ought to Srikanth and others in an analogous place contemplate when selecting amongst these three spectacular electrical SUVs? Right here’s a deeper dive into their execs and cons.
The Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 SUV: A Pinnacle of Electrical Luxurious
Benefits:
- Unparalleled Luxurious: The EQS 580 is actually a rolling suite, with supplies and craftsmanship that scream opulence. The Hyperscreen—a large, 56-inch show that spans the dashboard—is a tech marvel. Study extra about how this unimaginable display transforms the driving expertise in our in-depth evaluate of the EQS’s infotainment system right here.
- Consolation and Quietness: Air suspension and distinctive cabin insulation make for a whisper-quiet, clean journey.
- Three-Row Versatility: Whereas not as spacious as some opponents, the third row is satisfactory for youngsters or brief journeys.
- Service and Construct High quality: Many house owners reward Mercedes for offering a degree of service that Tesla typically struggles to match.
Disadvantages:
- Worth: Even used, the EQS 580 instructions a premium. Repairs out of guarantee is also pricey.
- Complexity: Superior tech can imply extra potential points down the highway.
The Kia EV9: Sensible and Full of Options
Benefits:
- Affordability: The EV9 provides spectacular worth for cash, with a beginning value considerably beneath the EQS 580 and Mannequin X. Kia’s funding in EVs is clearly paying off, and the EV9 has even begun to surpass the model’s well-liked Telluride in enchantment. Uncover how the EV9 is redefining Kia’s electrical future in our detailed evaluation right here.
- Guarantee: Kia’s industry-leading guarantee supplies peace of thoughts for brand spanking new patrons.
- Household-Oriented Design: With spacious seating, a contemporary inside, and an intuitive infotainment system, the EV9 is constructed for practicality.
- Reliability: As Grayson famous, the EV9 is more likely to be cheaper to restore and extra dependable out of guarantee.
Disadvantages:
- Luxurious Deficit: Whereas well-equipped, it doesn’t match the EQS when it comes to supplies or general refinement.
- Efficiency: It’s succesful however lacks the exhilarating acceleration of the EQS 580 or Tesla Mannequin X.
The Tesla Mannequin X: Futuristic and Enjoyable
Benefits:
- Efficiency: The Mannequin X’s Plaid model accelerates like a rocket, reaching 0-60 mph in as little as 2.5 seconds.
- Tech Management: Tesla’s Autopilot and Full Self-Driving capabilities stay unmatched, not less than in concept.
- Charging Community: Tesla’s Supercharger community supplies unparalleled comfort for highway journeys.
Disadvantages:
- Construct High quality: Tesla typically comes beneath hearth for inconsistent panel gaps and inside supplies.
- Service Woes: A number of house owners, together with Christopher, highlighted poor service experiences.
- Luxurious Hole: Regardless of its value, the Mannequin X doesn’t fairly ship the luxurious really feel of the EQS.
For Srikanth, it in the end comes all the way down to priorities. If luxurious and refinement are prime priorities, the Mercedes EQS 580 SUV is difficult to beat. If practicality and price range take priority, the Kia EV9 provides wonderful worth. And for many who crave cutting-edge tech and thrilling efficiency, the Tesla Mannequin X stays a robust contender.
What do you worth most in a three-row electrical SUV? Would you select the opulent Mercedes EQS 580, the dependable Kia EV9, or the tech-savvy Tesla Mannequin X? Be a part of the dialog and share your ideas beneath,
Armen Hareyan is the founder and the Editor in Chief of Torque Information. He based TorqueNews.com in 2010, which since then has been publishing professional information and evaluation concerning the automotive {industry}. He could be reached at Torque Information Twitter, Fb, Linkedin, and Youtube. He has greater than a decade of experience within the automotive {industry} with a particular curiosity in Tesla and electrical autos.