Tesla is about to unveil a automobile particularly designed to be a robotaxi, all whereas it’s nonetheless promoting its long-standing promise that its shopper autos would remodel into self-driving taxis by software program updates.
Some surprise if this can be a bait-and-switch.
Tesla’s Authentic Promise
Again in 2016, CEO Elon Musk promised that every one Tesla autos would quickly develop into totally self-driving and able to working as robotaxis, producing earnings for his or her homeowners by future software program updates. Initially, Musk claimed this is able to occur inside just a few years, however since 2019, he has mentioned it might be prepared “by the tip of the yr”—5 years in a row.
Recently, Musk has stopped making agency predictions. Nevertheless, this summer season, he hinted once more, saying, “I might be shocked if Tesla doesn’t obtain unsupervised self-driving subsequent yr.”
Tesla’s Self-Driving Technique vs. Opponents
Tesla’s method to autonomous driving is kind of completely different from rivals like Waymo and Cruise. As an alternative of counting on a mixture of sensors like radar and lidar, Tesla bets solely on a vision-based system powered by cameras and neural networks.
Since 2016, Tesla has bought its Full Self-Driving (FSD) package deal for as much as $15,000, promising that future software program updates will allow full autonomy. In contrast, Waymo and Cruise have already deployed totally self-driving autos in geo-fenced areas and function ride-hailing providers much like Uber. Their sensor-rich autos are already giving hundreds of autonomous rides every month, whereas Tesla’s system stays at Degree 2 autonomy—removed from the unsupervised self-driving Musk envisions.
Musk has criticized Waymo’s geo-fenced mannequin, claiming Tesla’s ambition is to exchange human drivers at scale, past restricted areas. However for now, Waymo appears far forward in delivering on autonomous driving.
Tesla’s self-driving {hardware} value a fraction of what Waymo’s system value and it doesn’t depend on mapping, but it surely additionally has but to work as promised.
Enter the Tesla Robotaxi
It’s unclear precisely how Tesla’s new robotaxi will match into this image. Musk has described it as a “devoted self-driving automobile” that may not also have a steering wheel or pedals, designed fully for autonomous operation.
The expertise powering this automobile’s self-driving capabilities is predicted to be comparable, if not similar, to Tesla’s present {hardware} in shopper autos. Nevertheless, updates are doable. The issue is that Tesla’s present Full Self-Driving program, based mostly on out there knowledge, is nowhere close to reaching the extent of autonomy needed for unsupervised driving.
For Tesla to function a steering wheel-less robotaxi, it might have to introduce geo-fenced, mapped environments—much like Waymo’s method. Tesla has additionally floated the thought of launching its personal ride-hailing service, known as the “Tesla Community,” however this has but to materialize.
Is This a Bait-and-Change?
Tesla homeowners who bought the FSD package deal will probably be watching intently on the robotaxi unveiling on October 10, particularly to see what {hardware} powers the self-driving options. If the robotaxi makes use of the identical {hardware} as present Teslas and operates in geo-fenced areas, this wouldn’t essentially be unhealthy information. Tesla might be engaged on its eventual commercialization – beginning in managed environments earlier than increasing its capabilities.
Nevertheless, if the robotaxi options new {hardware} that’s not out there or retrofittable for present Tesla autos, homeowners who invested in FSD might really feel Tesla has misled them. The priority is that their autos, regardless of guarantees, might by no means develop into totally autonomous robotaxis.
Electrek’s Take
There’s rising skepticism that Tesla’s HW3 autos, of which there are hundreds of thousands on the street, will ever obtain unsupervised self-driving. Final yr, Musk claimed FSD on HW3 was six months forward of HW4, however that timeline has since flipped. Contemplating Tesla wants a large enchancment in its self-driving system—roughly 1,000 occasions extra miles between crucial interventions — it’s laborious to see HW4 autos reaching unsupervised self-driving anytime quickly, not to mention HW3.
Tesla might not admit defeat on HW3 simply but, however this robotaxi unveiling will probably be an important second for the corporate’s self-driving guarantees and the purchasers who believed in them.
If it launches a geo-fenced robotaxi system with new {hardware}, I feel we may see Tesla begin to again observe a few of its claims about HW3 and even HW4 finally.
What do you assume? Tell us within the remark part beneath.
FTC: We use earnings incomes auto affiliate hyperlinks. Extra.
